allgemeines sturmabzeichen opinions please

[TIMOWSKI45]

Can anyone give their opinions on these two badges please, apologies for the poor photos.
Regards Peter

[bigmacglenn]

Both are original, the top badge was produced by Assmann...
cheers, Glenn

[harryamb2]

2 good ones.

[Stewy S]

First one's an earlyish Assmann. I'm not sure what maker is in the frame for #2. Better pics would help. Stewy

[Stewy S]

I'd really like a better look at the hinge, if possible. Stewy

[Stewy S]

Well, all of the hardware if you can get pics please. Stewy

[TIMOWSKI45]

Thank you for taking the time to comment gentlemen. More pictures.

[Stewy S]

A pin open pic of the hinge would help. Pin doesn't appear to be original IMO. It sits far too proud of the hinge for any maker I can think of. Stewy

[TIMOWSKI45]

Cheers stewy, some more.