-
-
04-08-2011 11:38 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
Re: on this Panzer ID disc!!!!
I don't have a good feeling about this one I'm afraid donkihotis- primarily because the blood group 'O' is the same as the 'O' in 'KDO', which is a problem because blood groups didn't start being put on Erkennungsmarken until sometime in mid-1941, yet with such a low Stammrollennummer, this man must have been serving with the Division before the war started. If the disc were made in 1939 at the latest, and the blood group letter put on two years later, it's pretty unlikely the exact same stamp set would be used; most of the time on regular wartime discs the blood group letter is different because it was only added by the unit after a man joined and was tested, while the disc was made previously.
It's also a famous unit, and what would be an incredibly rare disc- from the Division-Kommando- both make it a prime candidate for faking; I've only seen four or five Division-Kommando discs in 10 years of collecting and both from simple Infanterie-Divisionen (of which there were hundreds). There's also one further problem- while there are dots after the abbreviations, there isn't one after the '7'; in German, a dot after a number specifically indicates what in English we indicate by 'th' or 'rd', etc.- i.e., '7th' in German is specifically '7.', and that's the proper way it should be on an Erkennungsmarke. Of course the maker could have just missed it twice, but that's hard to believe since he remembered all the others, and taken with the issue of the blood group letter, is troubling.
It's a shame you bought it so long ago- unless the seller gave you a lifetime guarantee with matching return policy- because I, myself, wouldn't keep it...
Ohhhhh- pillage then burn...
-
Re: on this Panzer ID disc!!!!
Also there is no discernable wear on the neck cord holes which I would expect to see on a tag that has supposedly seen such long service.
-
Re: on this Panzer ID disc!!!!
Hi guys. Thanks for the replies, even though the news were bad. I have quite ebay buys because of the too many fakes. That one was one of my last purchases. Unfortunately i hadn't discovered the forum back then so i couldn't check it. It was suspicious to me the fact that it was a disc from a very desirable unit. The ghost division is very famous for it's achievements and especially because it was under Rommel's command, who is also a very popular personality.
I had checked the seller's other items and there were a few period magazines and books. It seemed normal to have an original disc since he had other original stuff. If he had some weird and suspicious EKs or other known fake awards i would have avoided it.
It was good that i finally found out about it's authenticity as it was troubling my mind.
Unfortunately after all this time it's impossible to claim anything back. It cost me $61 in an auction style purchase.
Looking for the photo albums of Leutnant Emil Freitag, 3. / G.R. 377
-
Re: on this Panzer ID disc!!!!
Maybe put it back on ebay and a reenactor might buy it? probably not for $61 but it's better than going in the trash.
-
Re: on this Panzer ID disc!!!!
The lack of wear and age are indeed a bit odd, although in my experience command discs are often pretty lacking in wear; I wondered if they may not have been worn constantly- as if higher officers, if that's whose discs they were, didn't wear them on cords but maybe kept them in their Soldbuch (there is a flap for the disc), or just in a pocket or something instead of on a cord. Or more generally that they weren't in action long but went back for a staff job someplace so didn't need to carry it at all or some such thing; so there are reasons why wear might not be present on what's supposed to be a disc that was held for a long time. This one's pretty clean though.
It's a bummer to have your suspicions agreed-with donkihotis, but if you were already wondering I suppose it's better to be as sure as you can be either way; I wouldn't want to always wonder myself. Unfortunately the trouble with Erkennungsmarken is that few people know how to authenticate them so even totally trustworthy sellers and dealers can have them without knowing. They're a specialty all to themselves so the general 'expert' on WWII German stuff probably can't do Erkennungsmarken well enough to spot more than the obvious fakes.
You needn't quit using ebaY altogether though, but rather seek opinions before buying- there are always folks here willing to help out It's advisable with any purchase these days it seems...
Ohhhhh- pillage then burn...
-
Bookmarks