Need some help on german badges

[Ryan B]

ANother craigslist find as ive been going through it. The medal in the center lookslike a definite fake but the other two are questionable for me.
What do you guys think?
Ryan

[dramos]

Are the photos stretched out?

[Walkwolf]

Pilot badge is bad, IMO. The wound badge looks good, but not in
the greatest shape - need to see the catch. It's entirely possible
that all 3 are fakes. Are these the best pics you can get ?

[Greenhorn]

Ryan

Your feelings are correct, pass on the middle one.

Mark

[Eric Zentner]

Middle one is fake.

Eric
Edit Mark got me on the same time post...

[Ryan B]

Yes for now, the wound badge is posted at 65$, and the 'Eagle" badge is posted at 25$.
Thanks
Ryan

[dramos]

I am no expert on the badges but at my first glance of the pictures I did not like the pilots badge either (and obviously not the middle one). I can not say whether or not the gold wound is good or not but I would say it stands a chance.

[dramos]

If the gold wound badge is real I think $65 is a pretty decent price, even with the bent pin. Plus you'd probably be able to get the seller down a little on the price.

[Ryan B]

I personally like the Lufty badge on what ive seen but, i am no where close to being an expert. Doug, do you have an idea on how much the gold wound badge is worth?
Thanks'
Ryan

[dramos]

I've seen them online on dealers sites in the 100's. Obviously it all depends on condition, like you know, but besides the pin the one you posted doesn't seem to be in that bad of shape. If we find out that the badge is real I personally would scoop it up for that price (after I tried to knock the price down first ).