Auction items .. Good, Bad or Indifferent ?

[Semper Fidelis]

Good original french type. Try to buy it for 400 zł and will be a good deal IMO.
Cheers.

[MichalMag]

Hello!

What about thic collar pennos? I've got my own opinion, but firstly i want to listen someone else

WWII Polish 7 Pulk Pancerny Collar Pair - eBay (item 150460989266 end time Jul-03-10 16:55:50 PDT)

Best Regards
Michal

[shuggymac1]

Any thoughts on this one?
I always struggle on this badge - there are so many repos around.
A

WWII Polish Army 1st Rifle Brigade Scottish Cap Badge on eBay (end time 26-Jun-10 23:19:06 BST)

Here is the photos - saved in my hard drive cache - sold for £155
god that is a lot of money for a badge

[wadowicznic]

Thank You
wa...

Good original french type. Try to buy it for 400 zł and will be a good deal IMO.
Cheers.

[Gary J]

Shuggymac1,

There was one sold on E-bay about a year ago that reached £320 GBP.
.. I think that £155 was a good buy..

Cheers

Gary J.

Here is the photos - saved in my hard drive cache - sold for £155
god that is a lot of money for a badge

[dorava]

Hello!

What about thic collar pennos? I've got my own opinion, but firstly i want to listen someone else

WWII Polish 7 Pulk Pancerny Collar Pair - eBay (item 150460989266 end time Jul-03-10 16:55:50 PDT)

Best Regards
Michal

Well I am defintely the doubting Thomas
Have seen similar ones before..and though these have the right spinner and right "look"...the ones I saw bent very easily....too much so...and I always wondered if they were Bialkiewicz made...or very late war cheap materials...dont know...sorry cant give more conclusive evidence regarding weights and such..
!

[A.J. Zawadzki]

What about these collar pennons? I've got my own opinion, but first I want to listen someone else . . .

Hi Michal,

Ahead of you sharing your thoughts with us, I can tell you for certain that these are die stamped. So if they are fake someone has gone to a lot of trouble to replicate the stamping dies.

Please don’t keep us in suspense for too long

Regards,
Tony

[dorava]

to put more wood on the fire..
I have heard that Bialkiewicz did make some copies of these pennons......michaelmag.....any thoughts.....<?

[dorava]

Hello!

What about thic collar pennos? I've got my own opinion, but firstly i want to listen someone else

WWII Polish 7 Pulk Pancerny Collar Pair - eBay (item 150460989266 end time Jul-03-10 16:55:50 PDT)

Best Regards
Michal

I guess others didnt think much of these pennons either
WWII Polish 7 Pulk Pancerny Collar Pair - eBay (item 150460989266 end time Jul-03-10 16:55:50 PDT)

a low price for these if original

[MichalMag]

Hello!

What i observed is that this pennons has strange column (look at the of of the columns, it has some kind of hollow?), also spinner is made of strange metal. I saw only silvered brass, this one looks to be made of white metal.

According to book "Barwa 7 Pulku Pancernego" collar pennons were lacquered, those from the e-bay looks to be enamel ware.

Maybe i"m wrong but in my opinion this pennons are post war for veterans, or maybe they are nice copies, who knows?

Best Regards
Michal