Hermann Aurich Infanterie Sturmabzeichen for review

[NineLives]

Hey guys,
Can I get an opinion on this badge, bronze or toned silver?

Thanks guys,



And thanks Fischer for all your time and help

[rbminis]

It sure looks bronze to me. Are these photos taken in natural light? Maybe a couple photos under different lighting would help.
Here is my silver to compare.
Ralph.

[fischer]

Hi Guys

For me, this one is a frosted, silver/white electroplated example that has darkened or toned with time.
Poor storage, moisture, etc. can turn these frosted finished variants a bronzy, golden tone and give the appearance of being a bronze grade ISA.

If you look at the reverse of the badge in question, it's my opinion there are still areas where the frosted finish can be seen.



The second example is another Aurich that has started turning brownish color in certain areas but, obviously this one is a silver grade.



And, here is a Hermann Aurich in my collection that has also darkened with time, but still has a little frosted finish remaining in a few spots, especially around the hinge plate that is crimped in place.



Best Regards, fischer

[fischer]

And finally, here is my bronze grade Hermann Aurich ISA.

Also, notice the hardware is bronze in color as well.
With the hardware attachment part of the reverse die process, the set up would have been coated when the badge was finished.

Not in the best condition but, one of the most difficult ISA's to track down.

Best Regards, fischer

[rbminis]

And, here is a Hermann Aurich in my collection that has also darkened with time, but still has a little frosted finish remaining in a few spots, especially around the hinge plate that is crimped in place.



Best Regards, fischer

That was my reason for opting for bronze.The original one posted shows no signs of silvering on the hinge plate.
Ralph.

[NineLives]

Thanks guys. Ralph, these photos are taken in natural light. Unfortunately I can't post the original photos from the seller as I am away from my computer

[harryamb2]

a silver one.nice.

[fischer]

That was my reason for opting for bronze.The original one posted shows no signs of silvering on the hinge plate.
Ralph.

Hi Ralph

Yes, with the angle of these pics it is difficult to see the hinge plate inside the crimping recess.

Here are the Dealer pics. I have increased the size of the hinge area.
I believe you can see the silver white hinge base-plate under the darkened areas.

Best Regards, fischer

[rbminis]

Thanks for posting those photos fischer!
Had I seen those to start with, my choice would indeed be silver.
Ralph.

[NineLives]

Thanks for posting up the photos fischer, my phone wouldn't allow me to. Thanks for the comments gentlemen