Tomaz so far we have seen this particular guard only on Wingen daggers with a slant grip.
Because of the early slant grip we placed him before the Wingen of Scott which we call an A.Wingen Type 1B, and called it the A.Wingen 1A.
We use the A & B version as the second Wingen is commonly known in the collectors world as Wingen 2 (the Gen. B look a like)
As you can see the brest, legs and beak are different from the Pack, its looks like a Pack 1 on steriods, so although the feathers may look like the Pack its for sure a different castmal ( picture on the leftside the Wingen, on the rightside the Pack)
That perhaps Pack provided the castmal to Wingen is always a possibility, but no proof have been found yet.
If this guard would have been extensively used by other makers like Pack, Tiger and Weyersberg then we would have crossed some in all these years of collecting, but we didnt.
Klaas is something else, that firm bought guards where he could find them when he was short on guards, so that one will not be taken into count, Klaas could have bought them from Wingen.
In this case if we had found this guard on at least 4 different makers then we would have introduced it as an early generic 3, so far we only succeeded in finding them on Wingen daggers.
So based on these facts and our own observations we decided to contribute it to Wingen.
We know that there will be others outthere and they will be sooner or later posted on forums, until new facts popup we contribute it to Wingen, time will tell Tomaz.
Best regards
Ger
Bookmarks