Some heer crossguards

[eraser619]

I need some help on these three. Is any of them original or not.

First one is made of alu i doubt this one the most looking at the casting around the swaz

[harryamb2]

I don't like any of them.mainly misshapen.

[paulscoot]

rubbish ,Where's the Quality.cheers Paul

[eraser619]

Too bad i was afraid they where bad. Need to find myself am original one but not an easy task.

[heers68]

I think it is unlikely that the second guard is a fake.. fairly rare early generic type used by Puma and a few other small quantity producers on initial production Heers. Should be brass based. Don't like the first, and cant see details on 3rd due to glare in pic. Good hunting. Kevin.

[gerrit]

Im with Kevin, second one is an early generic, had that crossguard on at least 2 of my early Heer daggers.
Jon calls them unattributed Puma/Voos, hope you dont mind Jon i used this one from your lovely wardaggers.com site

Regards,
Ger

[paulscoot]

Wow, you live & learn ,sorry about my earlier dismissal ,cheers Paul

[eraser619]

Thanks for the great info guy's