-
Thanks for your input Norm.
Wonderful and imformative,as always.
It has always been a puzzle to me why Schwerin used two sets of reverse dies on both tombak and zinc production,with the flat and dished back variants.and of course the two variant maker marks?
I was a little concerned at first about the badge that Leon posted in the thread opener.After comparing the maker marks with other examples i had on file i did beleive that it was a good one,even though i thought it was a flatback example from the images provided.
Hopefully,Leon can post more detailed images when he receives the badge ?
Cheers,Martin.
-
04-15-2014 02:25 AM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
Now,i am inclined to think that the smaller,wider spaced font examples with the flatback should be reffered to as type 1 IMO.
I say this because i think this type of badge was possibly the earliest of Schwerin's tombak BB production.
Here is an example that i have.It is a well worn tombak piece with a more "silver" type of obverse finish,not the heavy bluing that we seen on what i would consider later production pieces.This type of "silver" finish can also be seen on early type 1 Schwerin Destroyer badges.
The reverse features a domed head hinge pin,which also leads me to beleive it is an early production piece ?
I have bought and sold a few great looking Schwerin BB awards in he past,(pictured above) but i just love this old,worn piece and one i would never part with.
Regards,Martin.
-
Hi Martin,
That's excellent reasoning and I agree that's very likely the case. So you're suggesting the flat back variety began in Tombak, followed and overlapped by the dishback in Tombak to meet production needs, and then a transition to zinc using both sets of tooling? That would fit the observations.
Another observation that would fit that timeline, is the smaller font maker mark with the wider spaced rows is the same that Schwerin used on the Minesweeper badge which was introduced earlier than the Blockade Breaker badge so they perhaps early on had a stamp or template with this mark that was used during die production.
I'll update the comparative image to reverse the order of the two types.
Best regards,
---Norm
-
by
Norm F
Hi Martin,
That's excellent reasoning and I agree that's very likely the case. So you're suggesting the flat back variety began in Tombak, followed and overlapped by the dishback in Tombak to meet production needs, and then a transition to zinc using both sets of tooling? That would fit the observations.
Another observation that would fit that timeline, is the smaller font maker mark with the wider spaced rows is the same that Schwerin used on the Minesweeper badge which was introduced earlier than the Blockade Breaker badge so they perhaps early on had a stamp or template with this mark that was used during die production.
I'll update the comparative image to reverse the order of the two types.
Best regards,
---Norm
Hi Nom,
i am just basing my observations on the finish and the hingepin in this case.
I do think that the early badges by Schwerin had this less "blued" type of finish on the obverse and reverse.We can see this more "silver" type of finish on the type 1 Destroyer badges,as i have mentioned and on the early Minesweeper and Fleet badges also.
The later production pieces were the ones with the lovely "blued" finish and superb fire gilding,i think?
I just think that Schwerin's quality in regards to the finish on their tombak awards improved rapidly in the early war period ?
Then they went from tombak to zinc,and that's another story.
Regards,Martin.
-
Thanks Norm for your input and the detailed explanation, it is most appreciated. I will post some nice "close ups" when it arrives. Once again Martin, thank you for your thoughts and time. Leon.
-
-
-
Hi Leon,
I agree, a real beauty, and your last photo showing the oblique of the reverse nicely reveals the dishback contour. The badge is in excellent condition and I like the way the catch attachment is clear of the maker mark -- so often the solder obliterates the lower part of the mark. Congratulations on a great find.
Best regards,
---Norm
-
-
What a great looking badge. Congrats.
Unusual design and IMO 'restrained' in the sense, that it doesnt resemble the FLAK, sub or other badges.
Bookmarks