Cloth Back Lappland shield

[CBH]

I just wanted your views on this shield . I posted it on another thread but i thought I'd start a new one . It is backed in wool the thread used passed the burn test . The back side has a tar like substance on it . I was hoping someone might know if it's good or not . I've had it for maybe 20 years now . So no returns ! Thanks
Cheers Chris

[Adrian]

As mentioned in the other thread, originals are as rare as the proverbial rocking horse s**t and unless they come with provenance there is no way anyone can tell you a good one from a bad one.

They weren't made in a factory or by a noted manufacturer, they were made in the field so to speak and consequently, condition, quality and details will vary making it an impossible job to authenticate 100%.

[oradour]

Members would be best to search the forum, before asking for opinions...answers are there...if this fails then post, these shields were only discussed a couple of days ago, do not be frightened to do a bit of research.....it is surprisingly satisfying.
Prost ! Steve.

[pantherv]

I used to have this type of Lappland shield in my collection. It was never well received on the forums. Nevertheless in my opinion this type is original. Problem is you have to take this pieces on faith (Unless you can get one direct from a vet).

[KristianFerrell]

This is exactly the same as mine, down to the tar like substance on the back, just feels real flimsy to me, could be done in a POW camp, don't know, just letting you know someone else has the same one.

[Stewy S]

For me it's a '57er. All the details & shape are too precise. Remember the "original" ones (& I use that term loosely) were POW made, where resources were at a minimum. Or what the guards turned a blind eye to. Stewy

[big ned]

The problem with these is what do you compare them with? As said, POW made to no real set pattern using tools and materials that were available at the time, which wasn't the same everywhere was it?

Just for interest, here's a rare original in wear. Note also the de-nazified or '57 version EK1, IAB and wound badge as well.



Regards, Ned.

[Stewy S]

One thing I look for in Lappland shields is which direction the eagles head is looking. I know it's not much to go on but for me it's a starting point & I find the more believable ones face to the right as you look at the obverse. Which this does, I must admit. Any with backing always bother me. If you'd got away with making it behind the guards back, would you really bother with a backing cloth that you'd have to sew all the way round. Rather than three or for (usually three) fixing points? As I say, it's just something I keep an eye on. Stewy