SA Sportabzeichen to choose -need your advice

[Johnny]

Hey guys!!
I need advice.
I'm offered this two SA badges.I will take only one.which to choose?
I think that both are genuine.But you have more experience.
I believe that numbered is the one ( number 577719).It is older type as i have explored( type 2, 15. feb 1935 -Dezember 1938)
THANK YOU

[Johnny]

one more pic

[Adrian]

Can anyone help Johnny out with these badges?

[Carson3]

I would say that they are both very nice but I would have to take the darker one for it's pin is streighter then the other one.

[Adrian Stevenson]

Both look fine to me. I like the numbered badges personally.

Cheers, Ade.

[Glenn66]

I agree with Ade, the darker one also has more 'personality' due to the patina. I think the lighter one might have been cleaned/polished.

[MD Helmets]

I think they both look good. The one on the right doesn't strike me as having been cleaned. I think it just has a lot of its finish remaining. If you want one with darker patina I would go with the left one. it's really whichever one would make you happy.

[Johnny]

thank you guys!!!I also like darker.It has more 'personality.

[Glenn66]

Good choice!
When you get ambitious you should try for the full sports badge set...here's a little taster!

[Johnny]

wow