Two plates Ubootkriegsabzeichen?

[Gibello]

Greetings, I offer these two plates, I have to choose one, the price is the same.
You are saying.
What deserves more punishment choose?
Thank you very much.

1. Ubootkriegsabzeichen L/13

[Gibello]

2. Ubootkriegsabzeichen Wiedmann

[Gibello]

Which one you would choose if it is the same price?

[Datrus]

I am almost 100% sure they are both fake/repros. I see a "peagle" head and the wings are not even the same size. Wait for other to chime in.

[Gibello]

Thank you very much, I was almost 99% sure they were Original, now makes me doubt.
Thank you very much always good to learn

[Datrus]

It would be nice if others would chime in

[Adrian]

There is a link in the 'Useful Reference Links' thread which shows all types of original U-Boots Kriegsabzeichen so you can compare these.

[StuG III]

I would go for the Weidmann. To me it looks OK.

Tom

[KMMorris]

Is it me or is there a slight lack of line detail around the eagle.
But Reproduction IMO.

Morris

[StuG III]

Here's one for comparison.

Tom