I have bought a couple of items from him and found both transactions flawless
Maybe I was lucky
Nick
I have bought a couple of items from him and found both transactions flawless
Maybe I was lucky
Nick
"In all my years as a soldier, I have never seen men fight so hard." - SS Obergruppenfuhrer Wilhelm Bittrich - Arnhem
Hello all,
I purchased the remnants/scraps left over from an Estate he ravaged from the daughter of the collector. Craig left authentic items that were not in the best condition and cherry picked the rest. She stated that he talked her into listing some of her father's extremely unique and high-end swords on his auction site. The items listed did poorly and she got next to nothing for them. Weeks later she checked the site to cross-reference some of the items I was interested in, to see if he had anything similar. While checking for prices she came across several of her father's items listed for sale at over double what she was paid for them (he or his source purchased them only to list on the site)
I have not dealt with the man, nor can I prove the above events actually took place, but I can tell you the woman had a genuine disgust for Craig Gottlieb - at any rate, thought I would post here for reference.
William Kramer
I can only echo from hearsay all the above comments, but it is only what I have heard, as I have never had any dealings with him except on the other forum.
With any dealer, know what you want to buy, check and recheck and then ask for opinions as well, especially on the more expensive items. And then shop around and perhaps wait for someone else to have what your after, as it all (well nearly all) turns up elsewhere sooner or later.
Regards,
Jerry
Whatever its just an opinion.
Not sticking up for graig but if the daughter appeared unknowlegeable in the subject, sadly some dealers will take the p8ss.
Eitherway, graig didn't put a gun to her head, it was in her interest to do her homework to see where she could get the best deal.
As my father says 'if you act like a fool, people will treat you like a fool' (that's 2 of his phrases ive given away to you war relicer's)
Gottlieb is just another Ron Manion. Except uglier and shorter.
Just because he was in the Marines certainly does NOT make him a good guy either.
I've met him. And that about sums it up.
I have heard he has high quality fakes before ,coming from Germany .
He does not have a lot of friends in the militaria world ,the feedback always look to be bad.
He does have some interesting helmets for sale at the moments,but with the reputation of selling high quality fakes I would stay away.
chris
Similar Threads
Bookmarks