Third reich nazi paramilitary pewter souvenir plate from nürnberg - die stadt der reichsparteitage

[Horst]

Yeah, but I know its real and why. End of conversation.

Didn't say one way or the other just noted what I could observe from the pictures - As I noted would really like to have it in hand . Horst

[Australia]

it's not cast . Also I have never seen these faked or copied .

Feels and looks like Pressed 2 piece construction.

[Australia]

Are you sure? Looks like a triangle in the reflection to the rear of the plate. Its all high point wear which is typical, seen worse. You guy's are so fast to answer or open fire and the answers are right in front of you.


Attachment 683296

Erno , I had the hanger clip folded over . You are incorrect . They are the same

[Australia]

As we all know pewter is very very soft . 69 years of handling and god only knows what it had on it as a plate , will leave it not 100% crisp.
Also that these were not RZM Controlled as mentioned .

In the hand it feels right . The pewter has honest patina .

[Australia]

Also, the hanger on both pictured plates is different. Notice that one is rectangular and the other is triangular.

They are the same . I folded mine over for the pic .

[Adrian]

Ajax, wind your neck in and stop taking things personally.
This is a discussion forum where everyone is entitled to their opinion and to voice it.
You may not agree with others, they may not agree with you but don't be throwing your toys out the pram just because someone sees things differently from you.
Agree to disagree and move on.
If a reasonable discussion about different aspects of an item is beyond you then don't bother getting involved. Your comments are not the be all and end all of a discussion.

[Wagriff]

Okey...easy solution...simply send the plate to Me and I'll take care of it.....

[Erno]

They are the same . I folded mine over for the pic .

I see what you mean about the triangular hanger, but if you look closely, they still aren't the same, not that it has any significance. This type of hanger is still used on decorative objects today.

Attachment 683308

[Wagriff]

Not to be intrusive to a semi-private argument (heaven forbid), but were'nt these plates made over a period of several years? The Nuremberg Rallies were held from 1933 to 1938, Since these plates are undated and were "one of at least two Very Similar plates that attendees to the Nuremberg Rallies could buy and take home as their personal souvenir of the greatest annual get-together in Germany in Nazi times.", why is it unthinkable that there would not be small manufacturing and minor design detail changes over the years and between the various makers?

[Erich S]

A nice piece and I have one in my collection too.