Second Infanterie Sturmabzeichen opinions please?

[alfynokes]

Here is a second unmarked Sturmabzeichen, up for opinions. Thanks in advance again for all advice. Again the hardware catch seems very 'posh' compared to the rest of the badge in my very limited experience, and apologies again for my photographs.

[rbminis]

I believe this one to be a Steinhauer & Luck, also with a replaced catch or a variant.
Ralph.

[alfynokes]

Thanks Ralph, the catches on these two badges are very similar to each other.

[fischer]

Hello

This design has often been faked and I would need better pictures to authenticate this ISA.

Best Regards, fischer