Kriegsverdiesntkreuz 1.Klasse Manufacturer 51 or 15 Originals?

[Gibello]

I comentasteis the manufacturer 15 pieces in such a reproduction postwar era, I have offered these No. 51, says the seller, you have opinions?

thanks

Swords:







No Swords:

[Adrian]

I would not be happy with either of these Gibello. They are both fakes in my opinion, the materials look completely wrong.

[harryamb2]

there's somthing strange about them.

[Adrian Stevenson]

I would agree.

Cheers, Ade.

[Woolgar]

I agree, stay away

Nick

[octavian]

no. these dont add up at all.

[Martin Bull]

I've actually found this thread interesting. I'm very much a beginner in this subject but over the last few weeks have studied and read a lot about these medals - and have added a couple of original KvKs ( 2s, not 1s ) to my collection.
Many pics of genuine medals are posted on this Forum and I was rather embarrassed to ask if we could see some fakes. The medals pictured above certainly seem to have most of the right details in the right places - but somehow ( rather like a slightly out-of-focus photo ) they just don't 'look right'.

I certainly wouldn't buy them.

[Gibello]

Thank you very much for the feedback, I will pass these pieces directly post their comments, as it seems a modern assembly.

Thank you very much for the help.