2 Heer Falschirmjager badges: please provide opinions as to their originality

[panzerdad7466]

first looks to be made of zinc,,,second of aluminum...

[SteveR]

Could you get a photo of the makers marks please?

[Adrian Stevenson]

Both are fake in my opinion.

The zink badge lacks to die flaw to beneath the eagles beak. Makes it look like the eagle has a "beard" under it's beak.

Ironically, the aluminium badge has the die flaw which it should not.

Cheers, Ade.