Any thoughts based on the new photos? I suspect that none of the opinions will change since these photos are much clearer and focused, but would like to hear back from some of you nonetheless when you have the time.
I'm really on the fence. It's not a "one looker " by my personal parameters. This is one I would have to have in hand to examine and then see if I feel comfortable with.
Im afraid i,m still with Doug on this one, although i actually do like the camo acheme, theres still something bothering me with those liner pins, mainly that i think the pins have/had been removed prior to camo, but there should,nt have been any reason to, one of the pins especially looks to have undisturbed camo paint going under it as there is a straight line which follows through, plus its a different shade of camo, perhaps i,m being overly cautious, but my ideas of camo is a thicker application with defined brush strokes, this one seems to be very thin in paint, i really do hope im wrong and that you have a true camo, but in hand would be my preference as well
The rust looks a little red for my liking, bare metal on all my helmets is almost black.
Wow! Unexpected. We've gone from mostly positive feedback with the original pics to negative responses. Dave, I'm not in agreement with you regarding the paint application. Camo paint was scrubbed and reapplied in some instances, and in very thin layers. I don't think you can judge a good one over a bad one simply based on loose pins and the thickness of paint. I'd really hate to discredit a perfectly legit helmet (if indeed it is, and several here believe it is) due to technicalities that are not necessarily relevant to the piece. You mentioned different camo paint on one of the pins, but I'm not seeing it. Also, I've seen plenty of helmets with loose pins, which is what I think you're seeing here.
I'd really like to hear some more opinions on this from experienced helmet guys before I send it back to the original owner (the daughter of the veteran who brought it home).
Careful with the vet daughter story. Dave Shirlin got absolutely hosed by a "vets daughter".
In the end you have to be the judge as your the only one who has it in hand. Forum opinion is rather meaningless if you want this to be good rather than judge it on it's own merit for yourself.
And the reason opinions are all over the place is because better pics have now been posted and like I said --- it's not a "one looker".
Heres my tuppence worth- It looks as though at some point it has had a wire on the helmet when it has had one of the coats of paint applied. But to me the wear and paint build up around areas of the helmet as already said doesnt seem consistent. Just another opinion!
hope it is genuine for you.