-
-
09-28-2010 08:12 PM
# ADS
Circuit advertisement
-
Re: What Kind of sword is this? Yea I know its German WWII.
The examples both Fred and I posted, illustrate that the Ram dist. markings are contained under the reverse langets, meaning the markings on the blade were applied pre-assembly. The Rath markings on the saber in question could have been applied any time after the saber was assembled- meaning in 1942, 1972 or in 2002 for that matter. The location of the stamping is below the sabers ricasso and not in a spot covered by the langet. In short, the location of the stamp does not preclude the possibility that the stamp was applied post-war. We just don't know and won't know.
-
Re: What Kind of sword is this? Yea I know its German WWII.
I fully understand what you have been getting at now. On a side point was the marking in question ever a real mark by Hermann Rath?
-
Re: What Kind of sword is this? Yea I know its German WWII.
Gents, i have found this thread fascinating and very informative and technical, so from a purely outsiders point of view as one who knows very little about swords per se, i have to rely on your goodselves knowledge, however i look at items as i would a crime scene ie forensically, being an ex cop its something that sticks with you to a certain degree, Amongst the photos shown, the solingen stamp on both period and poss post war applied stamping, appear to have a trait in common, that is the N in solingen, both appear to be missing part of the downward stroke of the N. Would the fakers in the early seventies and onwards be able to produce the near same dies as the originals, bearing in mind that with the early periods of faking helmets it was quite crude in production and they are quite easily recognised as such, it would be interesting to have your points of view on this, thanks dave
-
Re: What Kind of sword is this? Yea I know its German WWII.
Dave. I believe the markings are not post war but applied after production. It has been said the original markings were removed and these applied. However as you point out the traits of the marking "N" are the same so what was referred to as real and post war applications must have been relatively the same time using the same dies. If the original markings were removed then why werent the "NEW MARKINGS" put in the same place. I believe this is not an SS sword but made under and by Herm, Rath and the SS and this mark is some sort of quality stamping. I do find it funny that noone else has weighed in.
Conspiracy theory. What if the person who marked these swords is on this board and owns one and wants to make everyone believe its real and discredit the others. LOL just kidding.
-
Bookmarks