New member who needs to help decide HJ badge

[HYPNOKRATES]

Hello,
I just started to grow other part of my collection. I collect NSDAP relics and related SS relics.

Now I have opportunity tu buy one of 2 golden HJ badges and I need help to decide. One is in better condition, but I'm not sure if it is original. Other seem much more to be original, but reverse side is confusing and it is not so nice as the other one. Both come from respected guy, but even him could obtain fakes.

Thank you very much.