Herresdolch-Portepee: Your opinions please !

[Maikowski]

Dear all,
I saw what is supposed to be a nearly mint Portepee for a Heer officer's dagger for sale and I would be very grateful if you could give me your opinions on it.
I must confess that the pictures that I am posting here are pictures of another Portepee that was sold earlier and by another seller. I am sorry about that but the one that I am interested in is 100% identical to this one, with the same celluloid package... and otherwise the only pictures of "my" specimen that I have are way too bad.
What do you think ? Was the one on the pictures genuine or was it too nice to be true ?
Thanks a lot in advance for your help
Maiko

[gerrit]

Its not an original.
I dont want these in my collection.
I will not tell you whats wrong with it, but believe me its a bad one.

Ger

[Anderson]

I would agree, a repro.

[Maikowski]

That's what I was fearing...
Thanks a lot to both of you.

Maiko