Two SA Sportabzeichen: advice before purchase

[Cyano]

Hello to all !

I have read good and bad reviews on this well-known seller, and I therefore wanted to have your opinion before purchasing this SA Sportabzeichen type 1 badge:







I also found this type 2 on another site. What do you think ?





If both seem authentic to you then I will be happy to buy them .

Thank you for your wise advice, dear fellow collectors.

[rbminis]

Please read the following thread, and then start a new thread for each of your Sportabzeichen separately.
Uploading photos and posting multiple items.
Ralph.