Pistols, Rifles, Machine Guns and Crew Served Weapons of Partitioned Poland and the Polish 2nd Republic
Article about: by stoggie I don't know what the K represents, but I do recall one for sale that also had that marking, and it was said to be from the Krakow armoury. For all I know it could be a inspector
-
11-04-2012, 08:40 AM
#121
-
11-04-2012, 08:58 AM
#122
Re: Pistols, Rifles, Machine Guns and Crew Served Weapons of Partitioned Poland and the Polish 2nd Republic
by
dastier
Did not mean to offend you Scout but you did say in your post: "nice simplified Browning design."
That is absolutely correct, I did say that....
No offence taken at all - especially as the words 'nice simplified Browning design' in no way mentions or refers to the GP. So how you get GP or High Power from that, I dont know......
Browning was so much more than just the footwork for the excellent GP, the laurels for which must go to Dieudonne Saive. JMB designed MANY firearms and many handguns.
Ahh, but now, I see where you went wrong; You want the Vis to be without ANY Browning influence at all (not just the influence from the GP which emerged at the same time, so kind of difficult for it to be copied) hence you latched unto my remark about Browning (that still does not explain, why you think my words mean the GP. I think you simply mixed something together in your mind).
Hardly the scope of this thread, but we could debate whether or not the Vis has any Browning influence at all.
As I mentioned in another post; at that point in time with the developement of auto handguns, how much variation of existing succesful working patterns can there be. Not doubt the Poles were aware of the 1911 and other JMB designs. Remember, there are MANY JMB pistols made BEFORE fabrication of the Vis commenced.
Of course, they were aware of the brilliant designs existing. They werent dumb - why mess with a good thing.
Just as the GP is a simplified 1911 design, the Vis is likewise....waaaait for it........ "a nice simplified Browning design."
Personally, I dont think, there can be much doubt about that, but maybe that discussion is for another thread.
Again, things were mixed together, as I talked about Browning designs, which in your mind somehow became the GP only.
Just a simple misunderstanding.
Inglis, Canada: GP blueprints were brought to the UK and then to Canada, where the GP was made by Inglis. Saive also left Belgium and worked for the Allies, as the German occupational machine rolled in.
Anyhow, back to other Polish items.
Strange duck, that Wz.38M
-
11-15-2012, 11:27 PM
#123
Re: Pistols, Rifles, Machine Guns and Crew Served Weapons of Partitioned Poland and the Polish 2nd Republic
by
Scout
Strange duck, that Wz.38M
They say that "necessity is the mother of invention..."
I find it more than interesting, in fact quite amazing, that Poland, a relatively poor country compared to it immediate neighbours and one that had been ravaged by war and stripped of its resources by its conquerors for so long was was on the verge of equipping at least some of its soldiers with wz.38M.
There is no telling if the wz.38M was going to be a boon or a bust or if it was ready for mass production. But consider that at the start of WW2 to the best of my knowledge only the United States and the Soviet Union were fielding semi automatic battle rifles in any quantity: the M1 Garand and the SVT 38.
I believe that the Czechs and Belgians had designs but am not sure if either were in mass production and the Nationalist Chinese were developing a semi auto rifle of their own. The Germans were developing their G41 and G43 rifles and the Swedes had their AG42 but neither were ready in 1939.
-
11-23-2012, 03:38 AM
#124
-
12-25-2012, 04:39 AM
#125
-
12-26-2012, 10:16 PM
#126
-
12-31-2012, 09:23 PM
#127
-
01-01-2013, 10:04 PM
#128
-
01-01-2013, 10:11 PM
#129
-
01-02-2013, 12:00 AM
#130
Similar Threads
-
-
In Field Gear & Equipment
-
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Bookmarks