Opinions on this clip sa

[Huddy]

Hello friends, please give your opinions on this clip
After looking through the thread, I didn't see a clip with three solder points anywhere.
Thanks for the opinions

[kabl]

Hello Huddy,
It's this so-called 3 hole copy...
3 solder holes on 3rd Reich buckle = fake
Looks here, the 2end post
Fake SA Buckles

Best regards from Germany
kabl

[Huddy]

Hello Kable, yes I was looking at the fake sa thread and that's why I thought the same, I just needed confirmation from more experienced people. Thank you with a friendly greeting Huddy

[ivanjoaquin]

Lately it seems that is accepted the possibility that not all buckles with three solder points are fakes
The roundel of this buckle is a known pattern of upright swastika SA buckles, the box looks correct, I do not like reverse cut prongs
I’m inclined to think the buckle might be original
It’s only my humble opinion

[kabl]

Hello Ivan,
Interesting comments on the 3 fastening points.
Do you have/would you have more input?
Thanks
kabl

[Huddy]

Good evening to all friends, I bought the buckle as original from a person who has owned it for over 20 years. I already have one from him, which I gave here for consultation and everything was fine. I am convinced that even he himself had no idea that it could be a fake clasp. He is willing to give me my money back without a problem. So is the buckle really fake?
Thanks a lot....regards Huddy

[Gwar]

Lately it seems that is accepted the possibility that not all buckles with three solder points are fakes
The roundel of this buckle is a known pattern of upright swastika SA buckles, the box looks correct, I do not like reverse cut prongs
I’m inclined to think the buckle might be original
It’s only my humble opinion

I have heard this for a few years now, especially from a well known buckle afficianado that belongs to a few groups and was active on the WAF.

[kirby]

I have never seen a three hole vertical row that I thought was real. I have seen some imperial with three holes in a triangle.

I don’t remember who posted this one hole buckle with the same roundel. I would say this example has a better chance of being real.

[ivanjoaquin]

I have never seen a three hole vertical row that I thought was real. I have seen some imperial with three holes in a triangle.

I don’t remember who posted this one hole buckle with the same roundel. I would say this example has a better chance of being real.

SA Buckles (Brass and Nickel) Upright Swastika

[kabl]

I have never seen a three hole vertical row that I thought was real. I have seen some imperial with three holes in a triangle..

This is also a my level of knowledge...
@Huddy,
On your buckle, the 3 fastening points lying in a vertical line and the differently sharpened claws (for me that) were ko...